Join Our Loyalty Program For Complimentary Gifts And Updates.

Italian Restaurant in Sarasota

Come to Bavaro’s Pizza for a delicious taste of Italy right here in Sarasota! If you’re looking for Italian Restaurants in Sarasota, our comprehensive menu features a wide range of authentic Italian lunch and dinner specials to fit any budget. On our exclusive menu, we can guarantee you to find your favorite Italian pasta and Pizza. Our long-standing tradition of serving traditional Italian dishes has made us a favorite among our long-term residents. The accommodating workers at Bavaro’s Pizza will make you feel right at home.

Bavaro’s Italian Restaurant Sarasota has always been built on the foundation of a family. It’s like coming home with servers who know your name and pasta that’s as good as Nonna’s. Our tried-and-true recipes – authentic Italian-style cuisine – have stayed the same as we’ve evolved and adapted to modern life.

People travel from all over Sarasota to Bavaro’s Pizza because of our friendly environment and delicious food served in large portions that can be eaten for lunch the next day. We are known for making every occasion a memorable one, from date night with your forever love to your niece’s quinceanera.

Why Choose Bavaro’s Pizza?

100% Homemade – At Bavaro’s Pizza, every dish is made from scratch on the premises. We have complete control over the ingredients used and the consistency and freshness of the dish since we make it from scratch. Trust me; you’ll be able to tell the difference.

Superior Value: If you’re looking for a good deal, Bavaro’s Pizza is the place to go. You’ll get a freshly prepared, 100 percent home-cooked meal with a portion size that won’t have you scratching your plate.

Flexible Menu – If you’re dining with three people or twenty, we can easily mix and match food combinations. There’s no need to compete for the last slice of Pizza!

Open 7 Days a Week – Craving something on a Sunday or Monday? That is not an issue. Our Italian Restaurant in Sarasota is available 24 hours a day, seven days a week.

Handmade Pizza, pasta, and calzones made from scratch, with dough made in-house, pizza sauce with local herbs, and the finest Florida tomato items will satisfy your hunger at any time of the day. Alternatively, you can choose from a wide range of pasta dishes, including homemade lasagna.

We can’t wait to become your favorite local restaurant in Sarasota! Whether you’re enjoying our fine casual dining or fulfilling a late-night craving at 10 pm!

Bavaro’s Pizza provides generous servings that can be shared or brought home for delicious leftovers. We look forward to welcoming you to Sarasota’s best-kept secret and up-and-coming neighborhood for fine, honest Italian cuisine. To experience a new wave of delicious food and service at Bavaro’s Pizza Italian Restaurant in Sarasota, call for reservations or stop by tonight!

Select Location
Select Location

Digital or Physical Menus Available

 Scan your smart phone over the QR code for a digital menu. 


Bavaro’s continues to operate in compliance with guidelines provided by the CDC. The safety of our guests and staff is important to us. Please remember to bring your masks and practice safe social distancing. We have indoor & outdoor seating at all of our Bavaro’s locations.  When you choose Bavaro’s, know that the following safety standards and practices are being met: